Fri, 5 Feb 1999 16:19:12 -0800
It's interesting that those who know something
about Ada give it 5 stars, and those who know
nothing (generally seem to be students) hate
the book and give it 1 star. Nothing in between.
Looks more like a failure of the professors who
assign a book not intended for students. I recall,
way back in ancient history, having a violently
negative reaction to Wirth's Pascal book (which,
to be fair, was pretty bad.) What they need is
an actual textbook, not a practitioner's book.
-- Dave Wood, Aonix
Pat Rogers wrote:
> As mentioned in earlier posts to comp.lang.ada, John's book has
> received only a few positive reviews and a number of very negative
> ones at amazon.com. The unfortunate effect is that the summary
> "stars" rating -- what one sees initially, without digging -- is IMHO
> very misleading and does damage to a fine book.
> Several people have indicated on c.l.a. that they had a high regard
> for the book, especially the second edition. Let me suggest to
> everyone that has both read and enjoyed John's book to go to
> www.amazon.com, do a ISBN search on 0201342936, and enter a review.
> Pat Rogers Training and Consulting in:
> http://www.classwide.com Deadline Schedulability Analysis
> [log in to unmask] Software Fault Tolerance
> (281)648-3165 Real-Time/OO Languages