Wed, 22 Jul 1998 15:03:33 -0700
In browsing some of the Team Ada archives I noticed a post (quite a while
ago) from someone who had quoted a paragraph out of Scott Myer's book
Effective C++. The para goes something like:
"Compilers are supposed to translate C++ into an executable
format, not act as your personal safety net. You want that kind
Program in Ada".
I cut/paste the para and sent it to a friend to read. He in turn landed up
forwarding it to Scott Myers who actually sent him a reply. For those who
may be interested the reply appears below:
>> >>I received an e-mail from a colleague quoting the line and
>> >>questioning whether the statement was indeed meant as a compliment to
>> >>Rather than speculate, I thought I would send an e-mail and find out.
>>"It's meant as neither compliment nor insult. It's actually supposed to
>>As a general rule, C/C++ programmers find it pretty awful that, in Ada,
>>can't assign an integer to a floating point variable without a cast. On
>>other hand, Ada programmers probably find it pretty awful that the result
>>the expression ? in C is 1. As a result, whether you view my comment in
>>book as compliment or insult probably depends on your point of view.
>>Thanks for writing,
Incidentally, there is an interesting thread on comp.lang.eiffel that is
presently running on such bugs in C++. The thread is titled "Bug Story"
and was started by Bertrand Meyer. During the ensuing discussions one
poster actually talked about a bug in his code regarding dividing int's by
float's causing him lots of wasted time - I don't remember the exact
problems but it was kind of interesting given the above comment in