Actually, at SIGAda, vendors presented several UML based tools that allow algorithms in state diagrams, with automatic generation of code. ------------------------------------------------------------ //SIGNED// Dr. Martin C. Carlisle Associate Professor and Advisor-in-Charge Department of Computer Science United States Air Force Academy -----Original Message----- From: Team Ada: Ada Programming Language Advocacy (83 & 95) [mailto:[log in to unmask]] On Behalf Of Paul Colin Gloster Sent: Friday, November 19, 2004 1:57 AM To: [log in to unmask] Subject: Re: If You Can't Beat Them, Join Them On Thu, Nov 18, 2004 at 08:12:42AM -0500, Roger Racine wrote: "[..] What does Java have that Ada doesn't? [..]" Inheritance anomalies. Nondeterminism. Incompatible attempts at JVMs implemented by Sun as reported in an attempt at a VHDL grammar with JavaCC. "[..] 1) Graphical approaches for flight control applications. Controls engineers have written their algorithms in diagrams since the 60s. If those diagrams can be automatically made into code, it saves a fair amount of effort. Thus, Simulink, Matlab, etc." Hardware design matured from unwieldly CAD schematics to text-like VHDL and Verilog. "2) Libraries. For guidance, navigation, and other applications that work in floating point (science applications in general), Matlab is an excellent example of an excellent design environment. Why? Because it has a large number of tools available to analyze the data coming out of the program. It is essentially a great code completion editor, compiler, and debugger in one integrated tool. It completes code by adding data declarations (I have never met a GN&C engineer who liked to declare their variables. "They are all double precision floating point anyway; why can't the system create them for me"). It takes the code ("M" files, in a proprietary programming language) and compiles it. And then the debugger allows the code to be executed using all sorts of data analysis routines. [..]" MATLAB is extremely weakly typed: I have seen someone with a doctorate who annually lectures the same material in digital signal processing accidentally let MATLAB (which provides no help in resolving the matter) perform a one dimensional Fast Fourier Transform on a two dimensional array which needed a 2D FFT.