This seems like a perfect opportunity to do some user research!  My
experience is that, in a standoff, we MUST ask users for input, since
they are the only ones who should tell us what's easier for them to
accomplish their goals.  Neither of you is wrong.  That's the problem.

Menus are very intuitive for navigation.  So are tabs.  So are links
on the left and links on the top.  So are buttons.  The function you
perform should be the label of the menu item, tab, or link.  It
depends on how many functions are on each screen, how many are
persistent, and so forth.  But primarily it depends on how your users
expect to accomplish the tasks.

So, I think that in this situation, my opinion (or yours, or
"Robert's") doesn't matter.  Ask the formally or informally
as your budget can handle.

Susan Ramlet

On Thu, 3 Mar 2005 20:47:25 -0500, Cindy Lu <[log in to unmask]> wrote:
> My fellow worker, Robert (not his real name), and I have been debating
> whether we need the menus (File, Edit, View, Help..) for a web application
> we are desiging (it's an application supporting some hardware downstream).
> He said Yes and I said No.  We can't convince each other. 

    Tip of the Day: Use the archives to research common questions
     CHI-WEB: POSTINGS: mailto:[log in to unmask]
              MODERATORS: mailto:[log in to unmask]